Heyday is a great album. My favorite songs are Myrrh, Already Yesterday, and As You Will. Columbus and the others are good too. You mentioned that Heyday keeps changing with P = A as your favorite Church. I know what you are talking about. I really can't decide which is my favorite Church album. It keeps changing. I would say that I like Heyday, Seance, and The Blurred Crusade the best. However, Starfish, ANET, Persia/ Remote Luxery/Sing Songs and A Quick Smoke at Spots are not far behind. As a whole I don't think HOB is a strong as the others, however I really like 4 songs off of that album, Anastesia, Louisana, Tranquility, and Buffalo. I still do not have GAF yet, but its on the way.